From Golf Course to Development Site
The West Lafayette Country Club, formerly known as the Elks Country Club, officially closed at the end of the 2024 golf season. The new owners, who purchased the property from the Elks, had agreed to continue operating it as a golf course through 2020 but extended that commitment through 2024. Despite their efforts, the course never turned a profit in those 11 years, leading the owners to consider redevelopment.
Zoning Change and Area Concerns
The proposal to redevelop the property has generated significant local discussion. Part of the land lies within a flood zone, and it borders the Capano neighborhood, a subdivision known for limited access and past flooding issues. Nearby residents have voiced concerns about potential drainage problems and the effects additional development may have on the area.
The developers are requesting an R1B zoning classification, which would allow for slightly higher-density single-family homes. The move has sparked debate about neighborhood character, infrastructure, and how best to balance growth with environmental challenges.
The Affordable Housing Connection
This zoning decision also connects to the broader conversation about housing affordability in Tippecanoe County. Allowing smaller lots and more compact homes can create opportunities for more attainable housing options, addressing some of the market pressures seen across the Greater Lafayette region. While the definition of “affordable” can vary, smaller and denser developments often provide an entry point for first-time homebuyers or those seeking more practical living spaces.
Decision by Tippecanoe County Commissioners
After initial review by the Area Plan Commission in November, the proposal was denied at that stage, though the Commission’s recommendation was only advisory. The matter then moved to the Tippecanoe County Commissioners for a final decision. During their meeting at the County Office Building, the Commissioners voted in favor of the rezoning to R1B, acknowledging that it represents just the first step in a long development process.
The land, as currently zoned, could legally host mobile home parks, solar fields, or other projects that may not fit surrounding land uses. Given those alternatives, residential development was viewed as the most suitable direction for the property.
Next Steps Before Construction
Approving the rezoning does not mean construction can begin immediately. The developers still must complete detailed site plans and obtain approvals related to drainage, road connections, highway access, and other infrastructure requirements. Each of these reviews could result in further revisions or denials before any building begins.
The process will take time and several stages of oversight to ensure responsible development that addresses flood mitigation and traffic flow. If proposals meet local standards, they will advance; if not, they may need significant adjustments.
Community Reactions and Ongoing Updates
Understandably, residents have mixed feelings about the changes. Many want to preserve open space and minimize flood risks, while others see an opportunity for new housing and revitalization in the area. The redevelopment marks the beginning of a longer conversation about how West Lafayette balances growth, affordability, and environmental impact.